© foto-ruhrgebiet / istockphoto.com
The continuous sale of a private beer mat collection is subject to VAT and income tax. This was decided by the 14th Senate of the Cologne Tax Court in its ruling of 4 March 2015 (14 K 188/13). The plaintiff earned his livelihood essentially through the sale of beer mats and beer labels from his father's private collection on eBay. The inherited collection comprised approximately 320,000 individual items and was continued by the plaintiff through additional purchases. Only duplicate items were sold. With this activity, the plaintiff generated annual eBay revenues of between 18,000 and 66,000 euros. The tax office estimated the plaintiff's profit at 20 % of revenue and also assessed VAT. In his action before the Cologne Tax Court, the plaintiff argued that he was not a dealer who buys and sells. He merely auctioned privately collected assets. Even if he were to be regarded as a commercial trader, the sale would not generate any profit, since the contribution value and the sales value were identical. The 14th Senate of the Cologne Tax Court did not follow this argument. It classified the plaintiff as an entrepreneur and commercial trader on account of his intensive and long-standing sales activities. The case was not comparable to the sale of a private collection "en bloc", which the BFH had classified as exempt from VAT. The plaintiff's income also constituted commercial income, because over many years he had acquired items intended for sale, both for consideration and free of charge. Finally, the profit estimate of 20 % of revenue was also not objectionable. The increase in value of the duplicate items had occurred within the business assets, since these had been intended for sale from the outset. The plaintiff had therefore contributed these to his business operations upon commencing his sales activity. Citations Case law Cologne Tax Court ruling 14 K 188/13 of 4 March 2015
Frequently asked questions
Frequently asked questions
Is the sale of a private collection via eBay subject to tax?
Yes, if sales are continuous and substantial in scope, they may be subject to income tax and VAT. The Fiscal Court of Cologne (judgment of 04.03.2015, 14 K 188/13) ruled that long-term and intensive selling activities lead to classification as an entrepreneur and commercial trader. The decisive factors are the scope, duration and frequency of the sales as well as the sales organisation.
When is an eBay seller considered an entrepreneur for VAT purposes?
An eBay seller is classified as an entrepreneur if they act on a sustained basis with the intention of generating income. Indicators include a high number of sales, long-term activity, and regular revenues of significant amounts. In the case decided, annual revenues ranged between 18,000 and 66,000 euros, which established entrepreneurial status.
How does selling a collection 'en bloc' differ from selling individual items?
According to BFH case law, the one-off sale of a private collection as a whole ('en bloc') qualifies as VAT-exempt asset management. By contrast, the ongoing sale of individual items over an extended period constitutes a sustained entrepreneurial activity. This distinction was decisive for the VAT liability in the ruling of the FG Köln.
How is profit determined for eBay sales from private collections?
If proper records are not kept, the tax office may estimate the profit. In the case before the Cologne Tax Court (FG Köln), an estimate of 20% of revenue was upheld as appropriate. The increase in value of items intended for sale accrues within the business assets once they are contributed to the commercial enterprise upon commencement of sales activity.
Are inherited items subject to income tax when resold?
If inherited items are resold on a sustained and systematic basis, this can generate commercial income. Additional purchases and the sale of duplicate items also indicate a commercial activity. The fact that the items originally came from an inheritance does not protect against classification as a commercial enterprise if the other characteristics of a commercial activity are met.